 |
Will Feliz start or close in
2011? |
The 2010 American League Rookie of the Year in
Major League Baseball is set to start his first game of the spring on Thursday.
Neftali Feliz was the closer for the AL champion
Texas Rangers last year, saving a rookie record 40 games and now, might make the move the starting rotation. This has been a debatable decision for some time with the departure of left-hander
Cliff Lee in the offseason.
The move is simply not a good one for the Rangers in the now nor the future. Texas has a lethal weapon in their bullpen with a firey young closer with great poise and an even better fastball. If the Rangers move Feliz to the rotation they will be taking away one of their strengths that helped them capture their first AL Pennant. Today, to contend for a World Series title in the majors, a top notch starting pitcher is need, someone that can lead a staff. This is what Texas thinks Feliz can be.
You also need a great closer to win in the postseason.
It has been stated many times by former and current players, along with people associated with baseball that the
New York Yankees do not win those four World Series titles in the late 90s without the contributions of closer
Mariano Rivera. He was the most valuable player on those teams and maybe in baseball the past decade and a half.
For example, look at
Atlanta Braves during the 90s. They had the best starting rotation throughout baseball and were in the postseason every year, but only won one World Series in that time period appearing in a total of three. If they had Rivera at the back end of their 'pen we might be talking about Atlanta as the team of the 90s, not New York.
There have been know to be exceptions like
Adam Wainwright of the
St. Louis Cardinals. Wainwright was a closer his first season in the big leagues and a good one, much like Feliz, leading the Cardinals to their first World Series title since 1982.
Wainwright has now turned into a front of the rotation starter for the Cardinals and is considered one of the best pitchers in baseball. On the other hand, there is story of
Joba Chamberlain. Chamberlain burst onto the scence in 2007, posting an unbelievable 0.38 ERA in 24 innings. The Yankees saw him as a front of the rotation starter, but Chamberlain's electric stuff did not translate into the rotation.
Now Chamberlain is back in the bullpen with an uncertain role and his career at a crossroad after it started so bright.
John Smoltz, who is a future Hall of Famer, also took on double duty. Here's the catch, Smoltz was a starter for the first 12 years of his big league career, winning a Cy Young in 1996 before ever getting a taste of the bullpen. Then after the 1999 season, Smoltz needed Tommy John surgery to repair his right elbow and missed the entire 2000 season. Coming off an injury and wanting to help the team in any way possible Smoltz moved to the bullpen in 2001 in an effort to stay healthy. Smoltz was successful in both roles eventually moving back to the rotation, but was a successful starter before the move to the bullpen.
Going from a closer to a starter is much more difficult than going from a successful starter to an elite closer, especially for a 22-year-old kid.
There is no question an ace is needed to lead your staff into the postseason, if Feliz proves to be that then he and the Rangers will silence all the critics, including myself. Although what if it fails? Then you leave not only the rotation a question mark, but also the back end of the bullpen.
The Rangers have made too many moves in the offseason with a team that fresh off their first World Series appearance in franchise history. They were in first-place well before they acquired Lee at the trade deadline last July. The
Seattle Mariners had two of the best starting pitchers in the game, Lee and
Felix Hernandez, to start the season, they finished 40 games under .500. A starting pitcher pitches every fifth day and can only impact that game, a closer can effect an entire series.
What if your starting pitcher goes eight scoreless innings and is clinging to 2-0 lead in the ninth and no closer to close the game? All that work of your starer is now gone with no one to secure the victory.
Chew on that.